Volume 9, Issue 4

Summer 2024

Editorial

Read  

What is ‘Strategic’? The Who, What, When, Where, and Why of Strategy

Emily Meierding, James J. Wirtz, Jeffrey A. Larsen

What makes a problem, operation, capability, or specific organization “strategic”? As the U.S. deterrence mission has broadened since the end of the Cold War, the meaning of “strategic” has become increasingly uncertain. In this article, we suggest a new way to categorize the contemporary use of the term strategic, while highlighting how current circumstances call for serious consideration of the question, “What is Strategic”?

Read  

The Misuse of Sun Tzu and the Cult of Maneuver

Ren Hongpeng

The theory of maneuver warfare, in the course of its development, was several times influenced by "Sun Tzu". Liddell Hart and John Boyd referred extensively to core concepts and theories claimed to come from Sun Tzu. However, these references to Sun Tzu are more of a misinterpretation or invention. This article is not a critique or endorsement of Sun Tzu, but a critique of such a phenomenon: ignoring historical context and using cases arbitrarily to serve themselves.

Read  

What is Missing in Peacekeeping? The Role of Strategy

Jonathan R. Beloff

The study and application of peacekeeping are often divorced from Strategic Theory. However, this lack of utilisation has led to a misunderstanding of warfare and conflict, which results in modest success or, more often than not, failed peacekeeping operations. This research examines the importance of incorporating Strategic Theory in peacekeeping through the case study of Rwanda’s experience and current deployment in African peacekeeping missions.

Read  

On Humility: Further Thoughts About Bad Strategy

Baptiste Alloui-Cros, M.L.R. Smith

Understanding of the reasons for bad strategy is still rudimentary. Reflecting upon how the conditions that lead to poor outcomes may be mitigated lies in the cultivation of a sense of strategic humility. This endeavour rejects the idea of strategic mastery in favour of open conversation that recognises the capacity of each of us to be a strategic learner.

Read  

Is Counterinsurgency Politically Possible?

John P. Connor

Western counterinsurgency theory has repeatedly failed to achieve victory. However, non-Western approaches to counterinsurgency offer a promising path forward.

Read  

Distilling the Complex: An Approach to Enabling Senior Leader Decision-making

David K. Spencer

This article provides tools for staff officers to describe the key issues for complex challenges in strategic and operational environments to enable senior leader decisions. It argues that staff officers can visualize and describe complex problems effectively by focusing on what a problem does, versus what it is, while ignoring unhelpful details.

Read